Tag Archives: comet

Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4

UPDATED 21:00 PST. 12/03/2013

More comet PANSTARRS tonight.  This time with the crescent moon, and a few aircraft trying to get into shot as usual:

Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones
 Nice Earthlight tonight, with light reflected from the Earth onto the part of the crescent moon that's in shadow from the sun.
Nice Earthlight tonight, with light reflected from the Earth onto the part of the crescent moon that’s in shadow from the sun.

Aircraft getting in on the act:

Comet, Moon, and aircraft with contrail illuminated by sun (below horizon)
Comet, Moon, and aircraft with contrail illuminated by sun (below horizon)
Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS C/2011 L4 12/03/2013 (aircraft in shot) 19:30-20:00 PST Los Angeles, Canon 7D 100-400mm L ©Tim Jones

UPDATED 20:00 PST. 11/03/2013

A couple more PANSTARRS pictures from Monday 11th March 2013 in the hills above Los Angeles.  I think the air was even clearer than last night, and there was no cloud to speak of.   First shot here includes an aircraft coming into LAX.  In the second shot, the bright point below the comet is Mars.  Hope to catch the crescent moon in shot on Wednesday 13th.

Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 11/03/2013 19:30-19:45 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 11/03/2013 19:30-19:45 PST Los Angeles. 0.5s, f.5.6, ISO 3200, Canon 7D 100-400mm L at 400mm ©Tim Jones

I was too busy last night finding the thing to notice, but I wouldn’t describe this as a ‘naked eye’ comet – so far.  Detectable in 7×40 binoculars; much better in 15 x 70s.

Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 11/03/2013 19:30-19:45 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 11/03/2013 19:30-19:45 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones

10th March 2013

Here are my first pictures of comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4, taken shortly after sunset from the hills above Los Angeles on 10th March 2013 between 19.30 and 19.45 PST.   I’m hoping to get some more shots when the comet is close to the moon on Wednesday 13th, and will update if successful.  Quite a challenging subject and my first comet!   Exposure info. for these: Canon 7D, 200mm and 400mm, f.5.0-5.6, 1/4 s to 1s, ISO 800 and 1600.

Picture from here 10th March 2013:

Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30-19:45 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30-19:45 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30-19:45 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30-19:45 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones
Comet PANSTARRS c/2011 L4 10/03/2013 19:30-19:45 PST Los Angeles ©Tim Jones

If you missed Pan-STARRS c/2011 L4, come back in 100 million years or so; or make your own comet.

Here’s an even better view of Pan-STARRS C/2012 L4, thanks to NASA:

From Un Autre Monde, Grandville, 1844
From Un Autre Monde, Grandville, 1844

Let’s Make A Comet

Having unaccountably failed to spot comet McNaught on its recent visit, I was compensated last week by a meeting with this artificial comet created at the Griffith Observatory .

comet
Demonstrator Grace holds the artificial comet (Photo:Tim Jones)

Demonstrator Grace is holding the tangible product of last Friday’s  ‘Let’s Make A Comet’ event, held in the Griffith’s Leonard Nimoy Event Horizon Theatre.   And I have to say, it was one of the best half hour’s worth of science communication I’ve seen.

I think the shear fun value had a lot to do with it.  And although the show was geared to a young audience, there was no dumbing down of the science or talking down to the kids.  Presentation style and jokes were witty rather than silly, patronising, or childish; and references to popular culture, like Harry Potter and the Transformers movie, were entertaining but topic-related.  The professionalism of the two demonstrators / presenters really made the show, and it’s taking nothing away from the scientific knowledge and skills these guys have, to say they were genuine entertainers.

The comet was made by mixing together common substances containing the elements found in real comets.  So that meant shaking up water, sand, carbon, and cleaning fluid (ammonia) together with dry-ice, or frozen CO2, in a plastic bag; the details are here on Griffith’s Teacher Resources page.

Griffith Observatory (Photo:Tim Jones)

I liked the hidden plan to pull an audience in on the promise of seeing a comet being made, then to educate them on broader themes and related topics; the practical demonstration happening only at the end of the session.   There was nothing sinister in that though, and it all went down well with the bulk of the show taken up with a mix of talk, slides, videos and Q&A breaks.  A lot of ground was covered, ranging from the chemical and physical requirements for life, to how the solar system is thought to have formed, and a pretty good introduction to astrobiology – including a discussion of extremophile life-forms.

Lecture theatre events are inevitably going to be a little one-way, but there was good engagement through the Q&As and frequent questions back to the audience. And it’s not like this was a public consultation on the risks of nanotechnology, the material being relatively uncontroversial.

Having the finished item available for inspection after the show was a big plus, and I’m sure the memory of it will for many people be a lasting anchor for the science they picked up.


Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, George?

The sun is shining, the outside doors are open, and from the window of the Royal Society library I can see the tops of trees along the Mall.

Michael Lemonick is introduced by the RS's Felicity Henderson
Michael Lemonick is introduced by the Royal Society's Felicity Henderson (photo, thanks Sven Klinge)

Today, at this first in a season of lunchtime talks at the RS, I’m learning from  Michael Lemonick some things I never knew about William and Caroline Herschel.

You can hear the audio and video (slides) yourself on the RS podcast page.  Lemonick’s book ‘The Georgian Star’ is published by W.W.Norton.Co.  In the meantime, this short commentary.

Michael Lemonick at the Royal Society (photo Sven Klinge)
Michael Lemonick at the Royal Society (photo, thanks Sven Klinge)

Sir William Herschel is best known as the discoverer of Uranus, a planet that did indeed in the days of William’s sponsor George III go by the popular name of George or ‘Georgium Sidus’ to be precise.  But discovering light blue planets that spin at a funny angle is only part of William’s and his sister Caroline’s  story.

Having moved to London from Germany, William Herschel the music teacher was enthralled by the stars he saw overhead whilst travelling between clients.  Disappointed with the telescopes of the day, he started to build a whole series of his own that would culminate in a 4ft mirrored, 40 ft long giant sponsored by the King himself.

William Herschel (photo WikiCommons)
William Herschel (photo WikiCommons)

Joined by his sister in Bath, both Herschel’s were professional astronomers in the pay of the King, making Caroline the first ever professional female astronomer (he on £200pa, she as ‘assistant’ on £50pa).

Between them they discovered 3000 galaxies, and Caroline alone identified 8 comets.  Uranus was mistakenly declared a comet on its discovery in 1781.  Impressively, the Herschel star charts were still in practical use into the 1950s and 60s.

catherine_herschel
Caroline Herschel

The Herschel’s were amongst the first astronomers to take an interest in the structure and evolution of the universe, rather than following the more practical motivations of the time – like enabling better navigation at sea.  William tried to measure stellar distance by the parallax method, but failed due to equipment sensitivity.  He was more successful at plotting out the shape of our galaxy – the Milky Way.

Herschel's plot of our galaxy (image WikiCommons)
Herschel's plot of our galaxy (image WikiCommons)

William Herschel is in some ways the father of infra-red astronomy, having discovered the infra-red region of the spectrum from its warming effect on bottles of liquid; he called them ‘calorific rays’.   As Lemonick pointed out, there seems some injustice in the naming of the James Webb space telescope due to launch in 2013, which will work predominantly in the IR spectral range (there is  a William Herschel telescope already on the Canary Islands) .

And lastly – I never knew this.   It was the common belief of the time, shared by Herschel, that all the planets were inhabited, with the sun just another planet – albeit a particularly bright golden one.

The logic extended to a belief that the luminescent surface of the sun was the visible top side of clouds and, charmingly, that sunspots were holes in the cloud through which – presumably with a powerful enough telescope – one could view ‘sun people’.    Those were the days…..